The Long Hill Observer

"Sunshine is the best disinfectant" Justice Louis D. Brandeis

Blog

For those students who wish to blog, you need to send me your email address so I can put you on the list. Click Here to email me.    

 

Who Is Henry Mintzberg?

Henry Mintzberg is an internationally renowned academic and author on business and management. He is currently the Cleghorn Professor of Management Studies at the Desautels Faculty of Management of McGill University in Montreal, Quebec, Canada, where he has been teaching since 1968, after earning his Master's degree in Management and Ph.D. from the MIT Sloan School of Management in 1965 and 1968 respectively.

Henry Mintzberg writes prolifically on the topics of management and business strategy, with more than 140 articles and thirteen books to his name. His seminal book, The Rise and Fall of Strategic Planning, criticizes some of the practices of strategic planning today and is considered required reading for anyone who seriously wants to consider taking on a strategy-making role within their organization. You can view his website at http://www.henrymintzberg.com/ .



MG 6103

Graduate Organizational Behavior

Syllabus

We will be adhering to the same syllabus as the other section being taught by Dr. Zinsser

Student Information Sheet

Organizational Worksheet Exercise

OB Model Worksheet

Readings and Assignments

Student PowerPoint Presentation

Case Assignment #1

This assignment calls for you to read Case Incident 1 - A Virtual Team at T.A. Stearns and answer questions about the case. The case is on p. 360, at the end of Chapter 10 (Understanding Work Teams).

This assignment is due in the drop box by Class Time Thursday 10/11. I expect a one to two page response to this case (1-inch margins, double-spaced, 12pt type). Please number your answers in relation to the five questions.

Answer my versions of the questions below, not the questions in the text. Make sure you answer each question fully.

1. Why is the group a team?

2. Has anyone in this case acted unethically? Explain your position.

3. What, if any, characteristics of groupthink are manifested in the work team?

4. Has Dave been an effective team leader? Explain your position.

5. What should Dave do now? What should he not do/avoid doing?

Note: In answering my version of Question 2, assume that the team members have in fact used their extra time to take time off and/or to work on consulting assignments for other organizations.

 

MG 2104

Undergraduate Organizational Behavior

Syllabus

Student PowerPoint Presentation

For those of you who still do not have the book, the library has two copies.

 

MG 7922

Financial Management of Information Technology Organizations

Syllabus

9/6/08: I understand that the textbook, Financing Information Technology; Greco, Joseph and Shahi, Gurinder, 2006, is in. Read the sections pertaining to Asset Management for our next meeting. In addition, I have come across some interesting articles on Asset Management that you might want to read and discuss in class. Click on the links below to access them.

Session 1: Introduction to IT Financial Management

Economics of Information Technology

CIO's Must Transcend Expectations

IT Gets Respect; CIOs Share Secrets

Session 2: Asset Management

The Measurement and Recognition of Intangible Assets

Computer Software: The Revenue Recognition Issues

A Valuation Model for Software

Inadequate Controls Over IT Equipment at the VA

Session 3: Continuation of Session 2.

Also Read "How is the credit crunch impacting your economy?"

Accounting vs. Technology - Who’s At Fault

Tonight we will be discussing ratio analysis of technology companies. In addition, we will continue creating a technology company, divide up responsibilities and discuss financing.

Music

The Velvet Underground

By far, the most influential group to have ever come out of New York City is The Velvet Underground. Artist Andy Warhol took them under his wing in 1966 and music was never the same. They have been "iconized" in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.

Lou  

 

 

 

 

Bob Dylan

Although not a native of New York City, Bob Dylan was as much the Greenwich Village scene as any New Yorker.

 

Art

This is by no means a complete listing of sixties artists. They are, however, some of my favorites

Andy Warhol

Birth of Venus Art Print by Andy Warhol

Helen Frankenthaler

Claes Oldenburg

Allan Kaprow

Allan Kaprow, Calling

 

   

Management: Science, theory or philosophy?

by Howard A. Kupferman

Many pundits of management “theory” or management “science” emphasize the quantitative aspects of managing organizations. There is certainly room for studying statistics and analyzing the effects of different management styles in terms of cause and effect, however, not everything is so simple. In fact, as soon as someone builds a better management mousetrap, some of the mice just become more indignant. In addition, human beings are much more complex. “Experiments” which work on animals do not necessarily translate into results for human beings. In addition, science is defined by use of the scientific method, for which replication of any experimental result is essential and will lead to certain “laws”, such as the laws of non-subatomic physics. No matter the weight of the object, it will always descend at 32 feet per second squared. The same cannot be said for the likes of what is referred to as motivation theory. This is why it is referred to as a theory, and not motivation science. In that the theory of evolution cannot be proven by the scientific method, it remains a theory and not an absolute. 

It would seem to most that modern management philosophy, the word emanating from the Greek meaning “love of knowledge”, and I will refer to the discipline as a philosophy throughout this essay, is something that has developed in western industrialized society only within the past 100 years. It is, by its nature, an effort to create a productive workforce. In fact, the treatment of slaves in the ancient world was also management of labor, labor being one of the pillars of economics, albeit under a very different economic system. Management philosophy in the modern era appears to revolve around one central theme; how to get people, who have relative choice, to choose commitment to the tasks that are beneficial to the organization for which they work. Some of these organizations are for the sole purpose of creating wealth. Others are for the sole purpose of distributing social services. Others are for administering laws. Whatever the purpose of the organization, employee commitment is “desirable”, but not essential. During times in which employment opportunities are scarce, economic factors allow for a relaxation of those techniques used to enhance productivity among a certain percentage of the labor force. By the very nature of the essentiality of purpose of these organizations, it is doubtful that any serious attempt will be made to study the effects of such relaxation utilizing the scientific method. 

Much has been made of measurement. Researchers attempt to measure employee performance in much the same way they measure other aspects of business. Performance ratings are assigned to employees in order to determine value to the organization and for the purpose of administering some kind of reward structure. Intervention is suggested when management “believes” there is room for further productivity gains. Management’s belief is sometimes founded upon qualitative observation, sometimes quantitative measurement, but many times it is nothing more than wishful thinking. Whatever the method, it is usually based upon the belief that it is possible to enhance employee productivity without investing capital. As most economists would agree, production is significantly impacted only by capital investment. (This is, of course, only a theory in that it has been studied by observation and not experimentation utilizing the scientific method.) 

In addition, techniques which seem to work for a certain percentage of the population have no effect on a large portion of the labor force. The use of statistics to describe the variability of outcomes may be significant in efforts to predict human behavior. However, the philosophy, which is then treated as theory when there is an effort to prove that it has validity, can never become a law because the outcome does not occur 100% of the time, thus the need for the use of statistics in describing “probability”. Use of the word “science” in discussing such philosophies such as economics and psychology, is an effort by those theorists to create the illusion of certainty where there is none. The admission that the probabilities of outcomes, when certain methods of management are utilized, are not necessarily cross cultural is evidence that these theories are not really theories at all in the sense that efforts are made to prove them scientifically. The same is said of other “soft” sciences. Essentially, science cannot be soft; a belief is either subject to the scientific method or it is not. If it is not, then, by definition, it cannot be a science. 

Therefore, we are left without evidence that management is a science. We are also left with the fact that its tenets are not theories that are subject to the scientific method. These facts dictate that we must relegate the practice of enticing labor to be more productive without capital investment to the realm of philosophy. If such a practice is subject to the dictates of philosophy, we must use those methods to discuss and debate its inherencies and relevance. Such inherencies must, by their very nature, be cross cultural. The reason such philosophical ideas emanating from individuals such as Aristotle and Locke are relevant even today is the cross cultural nature of their arguments. Management philosophy must follow the same pattern. Otherwise, its tenets will change over time. 

Management practitioners would be better served if such universal tenets were developed. These can only be developed through the resolution of the arguments via philosophical debate. Rather than construe the management “wisdom” that has been developed over the past 100 years as management theory or law, those interested in developing a philosophy which will traverse the eons, as have those of Socrates, Aristotle and Plato, would be better off studying the art of logic and resolution of philosophical argument.

Hit Counter